Okay, so lets face it, we ALL know that several rounds in the game were rigged, and I figure that now that the game is over we can fess up and admit how we would have truly voted.
I’ll start: TinyTall, your round was rigged. Matt and I communicated after the panel was set up since he was my strongest ally in the game. Jimmy (The Rev.) is a good friend of mine and we debated together at the coop (we actually faced Kyle, the other judge during one of our rounds, but his ballot was uninfluenced). Essentially, the round was set up unfairly, I didn’t really understand why Jimmy and I got to judge on the same panel.
Absent game-politics, I probably would have voted for stanford since the K was dropped. However, it was really close since the K was somewhat lacking in dispositional analysis, which came out somewhat late. It was a close round. And you did well.
Okay… time for the next confession: